aristotle rodor

52! Week Forty-Four

Eric P. I.Leave a comment
By Johns, Morrison, Rucka, Waid, Giffen, Barrows, Green, Ramos, Baron, Leigh, Richards, Schaeffer, and Siglain. Cover by Jones and Sinclair.

52 was a weekly series published by DC Comics starting in May, 2006. Because I had my 52nd birthday in late 2020, I thought it might be interesting (fun?) to examine this series for its 15th anniversary. I plan to post once a week about each issue. To read previous posts, click the link (52!).

Synopsis

“Deaths in the Family”

Week 44, Day 1

Black Adam is struck by lightning, and he tells Isis that Osiris’s power has returned to him. They find Amon dead and Sobek reveals that he is Yurrd, the Unknown, also known as Famine. The other three Horsemen of Apokolips arrive and attack the couple. Black Adam breaks Yurrd’s mouth, and Pestilence infects Isis with its disease. Death is about to kill her when Adam uses one of War’s guns to stop it. He kills Pestilence, and Isis then calls up lava to help Adam against Death, who then flees. Before she dies, Isis tells Adam he was right and that he should avenge her and Amon.

In Nanda Parbat, Renee knows that Isis has died when the flower the demi-goddess gave her wilts away. When she wonders how Adam and Osiris will cope, Tot and Richard Dragon tells her to find out. Tot gives her Charlie’s hat and coat, but she rejects the notion, “I’m not going to be him”. Dragon convinces her that some questions “can only be answered by wearing a mask,” and she dons the hat, a tear falling down her cheek.

Thoughts

I love this cover — the blood on the white background, the reflection of Isis in her brother’s blood — it’s an indication and a portent. I’d love to know how Jones and Sinclair created the splatter and spray — is it just Photoshop brushes?

So the whole Oolong Island machinations were because  Black Adam refused Intergang’s offer in issue 3? What of the Darkseid connection and the Crime Bible? This just looks more like crime family squabbling, but I suppose DC needed to revert Adam somehow. How many times will they continue to play with that toy? It’s become a specific Black Adam trope (they’re doing it now in Justice League). Also, I felt it was too easy for Isis to tell Adam, you were right, destroy the evil in the world and avenge us. Or would that be hackneyed to have Adam struggle against his baser nature and his wife’s dying plea to not succumb to pain and rage?

RIP Isis, we hardly knew ye. It’s especially poignant because at the time of this writing, JoAnna Cameron, who played the character on The Secrets of Isis television series, died within the last week. I would have loved to have seen this character interact more with the larger DCU. I know they brought the character back, but I doubt she’s the same. Perhaps I will seek out her other appearances (including the 1970s The Mighty Isis series).

Last post, I described Sobek biting Amon’s head off as he tried to speak Black Adam’s name, but in this issue, Amon’s head is still attached. Also, given Sobek’s hunger, I would have expected there to be less of Amon intact. Perhaps DC editorial didn’t want to go too bloody (the cover notwithstanding).

As for the arrival of the other Horsemen of Apokolips or Monster Society or whatever, they are pretty much a nothing burger, aren’t they? Sure, two of them kill a super being each (well, one really), but four of them couldn’t take out Black Adam, so they are hardly the threat I think the Oolong scientists thought they were. Perhaps I’m missing something and should go read 52 Aftermath: The Four Horsemen? (Probably not.) Also, I hoped to have some connection with Veronica Cale given her tears at the sight of these creatures when they left Oolong Island (issue 38). Perhaps that’s to come, but I would have preferred that to the end scene with Renee sort of donning the guise of the Question. I do appreciate, however, that when she puts on the hat, her face is partially obscured, foreshadowing the inevitable (and obvious). It is the last vestige of her as simply Renee Montoya, much like it’s the last remnant of Black Adam, benevolent ruler.

I feel like I have wondered in these posts if the Marvel family members shared the power, meaning that Captain Marvel is actually weaker because Marvel Jr and Mary have a part of his power. This seems to have been confirmed because when Amon died, Black Adam is hit by lightning (which is a nice visual for that) and he tells Isis that “I feel … stronger. [Osiris’s powers] have returned to me.” Maybe this is well known to Shazam-o-philes, but I had always been curious.

Finally, this issue contains a house ad for the series, asking us if we have solved the mystery. There are pictures of characters representing the major storylines of the series, with Rip Hunter’s crazy chalkboard in the background. I reviewed my post about issue 6 where those chalkboards appeared and while some things have been revealed since then, there really hasn’t been a resolution to a lot of the items, meaning there’s a whole lot of revelation needing to happen in the next eight issues.

52! Week Twenty-Seven

Eric P. I.Leave a comment
By Johns, Morrison, Rucka, Waid, Giffen, Moll, Jose, Benes, Ramos, Rollins, Nelson, Pantazis, Brosseau, Richards, Schaefer, Wacker, Siglain. Cover by Jones and Sinclair.

52 was a weekly series published by DC Comics starting in May, 2006. Because I had my 52nd birthday in late 2020, I thought it might be interesting (fun?) to examine this series for its 15th anniversary. I plan to post once a week about each issue. To read previous posts, click the link (52!).

Synopsis

“The Past Best Hope”

Week 27, Day 1

Ralph Dibny takes charge of his journey with the Helmet of Fate and they visit the Spectre. Ralph asks if the Hand of God can bring his wife back, to which the Spectre declares, smiling, “Absolutely”. Spectre then takes Ralph and the Helmet of Fate to deep space where the Eclipso possessed Jean Loring is imprisoned. Ralph accepts the Spectre’s bargain, and Ralph tells Jean Loring, “I’ll show you hell …”.

Week 27, Day 2

Elsewhere, Waverider sits in a room with many clocks. At 5:25:20 a.m., the Time Commander appears, trapped in an hourglass. He chastises Waverider for betraying him and the other time stealers and then disappears. Immediately, Skeets appears, and Waverider asks it if it’s Skeets’ fault, “You’re the one Rip Hunter was warning us about”. Skeets’ denies that it is not the one who is “splintering the historical mainline”, but demands to know when is Rip Hunter. It proceeds to torture Waverider for the information.

Week 27, Day 5

While Richard Dragon trains Renee Montoya, she discovers that Charlie has cancer and doesn’t have long to live. Meanwhile, Aristotle Rodor examines the Crime Bible and one particular passage makes Renee think that Kate Kane is in danger.

Week -84, Day -2

Ralph has transported Jean to the past, to the moment before she has called Sue and murdered her. Using Spectre-given power, Ralph transforms Jean, suppressing the Eclipso entity so that Jean will experience the guilt in an eternal loop. Jean begs for forgiveness, and as the phone rings, she turns to Ralph, telling him, “Ralph … look away … You’re only punishing yourself …”. Ralph screams and takes them back to space, his deal with the Spectre undone. Ralph tells the Helmet that he knows that he can get Sue back, and to do that, they need to go to Nanda Parbat.

Thoughts

First, I love the detail that Jones and Sinclair put into the Spectre’s hood and glove — they look like they’re made of actual fabric! Speaking of the Spectre, his (its?) smile when he says to Ralph, “Absolutely!”, is creepy as hell.

I love that the confrontation between Waverider (Is this room full of clocks where he was last issue too? Was he hiding specifically from Skeets or something more sinister?) and Skeets lasts in between the space of one second. I know they had to use the 5:25:20 time to make the 52 reference work, but is there some significance to two fifty-twos? Is this a heretofore unknown reference to the Dark Multiverse? ;)

Charlie dying is one of the main things I do remember about 52, and Renee taking on the mantle of the Question was one of the best things to come out of the series (besides the reveal of the return of the multiverse).

But it is the scene set in the past that is the best part of this issue. First, I love the negative values of the time caption — who had to figure that out and is it even accurate?! I have to wonder if the issue title is a play on a line from Lincoln’s second State of the Union, “the last best hope” (please don’t tell me whomever chose that title was merely a Babylon 5 fan …)? If so, the “best hope” has to be a reference to Jean Loring’s redemption, right? That brief moment when she shows concern for Ralph was very moving. Anyway, I found it interesting that DC wanted to redeem Jean to a degree, while still having her remain as Eclipso (I was never a fan of her in that role). Now I want to find out what happened to her next.

The Origin of Black Canary

by Waid, Chaykin, Pantazis, Napolitano, Richards, Schaefer, Siglain

Did Dinah’s mother get pissed at her teammates going behind her back to train her daughter? I would be. I did like that they didn’t mention the events in The Longbow Hunters, something that seems to define and haunt Black Canary.

52! Week Twenty-Six

Eric P. I.Leave a comment
By Johns, Morrison, Rucka, Waid, Giffen, Olliffe, Geraci, Pantazis, Brosseau, Richards, Schaefer, Wacker. Cover by Jones and Sinclair.

52 was a weekly series published by DC Comics starting in May, 2006. Because I had my 52nd birthday in late 2020, I thought it might be interesting (fun?) to examine this series for its 15th anniversary. I plan to post once a week about each issue. To read previous posts, click the link (52!).

Synopsis

“Halfway House”

Week 26, Day 1

The Black Marvel family transport Renee Montoya and Charlie 57 km east of Nanda Parbat, where they are greeted by Aristotle Rodor and Richard Dragon, who announces to Renee in a cryptic way that class is now in session.

Week 26, Day 2

John Henry Irons, Steel, appears on Jack Ryder’s talk show, You Are Wrong, to voice his accusations against Lex Luthor’s Everyman project. Natasha joins the interview to refute her uncle, and then gets a call about an explosion and she rushes off to help.

Week 26, Day 4

The Black Marvel family join Dr. Sivana’s ex-wife, Venus, and their children — Junior, Georgia, Beautia, and Magnificus — for dinner. Lady Sivana then requests the Black Marvels’ help in locating the missing Dr. Sivana.

At Oolong Island, Dr. Cale arrives to help the other assembled mad scientists with the Four Horsemen project.

Bored at dinner, Osiris leaves, and then the rest are seemingly attacked by a mutated crocodile, who grabs some food off the table and escapes. Later, Osiris encounters the crocodile man who tells Oriris that Dr. Sivana experimented on him, turning him into the creature he now is, and that he is so very hungry.

Thoughts

I love the old Hollywood horror movie inspired cover. It teases us with the red coming from the Black Marvel family but ending in a claw shape — is the claw symbolism? Plus, while red here denotes evil or blood or danger (at minimum), you get to see Black Adam in Captain Marvel red and yellow, which totally subverts the symbolism while reinforcing it. Deftly conceived by Jones, and, my god, Sinclair owns this image with the beautiful coloring.

The cover title, “The Beast Who Came to Dinner”, is a much more descriptive one (if perhaps too on the nose), but the writers/editors just had to be cute and call attention  to the fact that we’re now halfway through the series (where is the “halfway house” concept in this issue anyway? Perhaps Nanda Parbat for Renee?). And now that we are halfway, where are we in the story? Not that closer to resolving any of the mysteries or conflicts set up for the last 25 issues, but perhaps setting all that up was the point of the previous act? And we get even more characters thrown into the mix! Given how many creators are on this book and all of the characters and plots, this series should have been a disaster. Thank goodness it wasn’t, but I’m now thinking they put form over function a bit, sort of how a television series will often have some “filler” shows to meet that 22-24 episode requirement, i.e., some of these plots are a bit thin and they just keep stretching them out (I’m looking squarely at you Irons family drama) to fill 52 weekly issues.

Specifically regarding this issue, I do like the little flourish that Olliffe adds in the first scene with flowers springing up on the ground where Isis stepped.

The whole scene with the Sivana children was a nice comedic distraction. It also sets up a future, potential plot-point with Waverider appearing briefly on a monitor, saying, “I know why.” And there’s something about the fact that Venus Sivana’s $20M donation to Kahndaq’s children’s hospital makes Black Adam accept her dinner invitation — he’s become quite the politician in such a short time.

Finally, a minor quibble. Ii the Oolong Island scene, some dialog is mixed up in the last panel where it appears that Dr. T. O. Morrow addresses Dr. Magnus as “Morrow”, or perhaps he’s just entered that phase of megalomania where you refer to yourself in the third person.

The Origin of Hawkman and Hawkgirl

by Waid, Bennett, Jose, Sinclair, Brosseau, Richards, Wacker

This describes accurately the state of affairs of Hawkman and Hawkgirl at the time of publication, leaving out the creepy way that Carter hit on Kendra. That was the only misstep of the Hawkman reboot started in the JSA series and continued in the Hawkman (2002) title.